An Italian judge has halted the trial of four Egyptians accused of killing Italian student, Giulio Regeni amid concerns that the accused do not know they have been charged, bitterly disappointing his family.
Judge Antonella Capri ruled in favour of the lawyers for the defence who argued the proceedings would be void without proof that the four charged were aware of the case against them.
The case will now go back to a preliminary court and it will be decided whether to try to find the accused.
Four Egyptian security forces members were due to go on trial in absentia in Rome, accused of the kidnapping, torture and killing of Regeni, whose mutilated body was found in a ditch near Cairo in February 2016.
The Egyptian authorities rejected the Italian allegations about Regeni’s killing. Prosecutors accused them of withholding the accused men’s whereabouts and hindering the investigation.
Italy’s government is a civil party in the case – a show of support to the victim’s family. Regeni’s parents and sister were at the trial.
Quoted by Reuters news agency, the family’s lawyer Alessandra Ballerini said the decision was “a setback, but we are not going to give up.”
“We demand that those who tortured and killed Giulio do not go unpunished,” she reportedly said.
The 28-year-old student was abducted on 25 January 2016 while carrying out research for his PhD at Cambridge on Egypt’s independent trade unions. A week later his body was discovered on the road to Alexandria.
The BBC’s Mark Lowen in Rome reports that the Egyptian authorities constantly hindered the Italian prosecution, inventing wild stories behind the murder: a failed drug deal, a botched robbery, even a gay crime of passion.
But Italian prosecutors concluded that the Egyptian national security agency was behind the murder.
They said Regeni had been under surveillance for weeks and reported as a spy by a Cairo street trade unionist. Before he died he was kicked, punched, cut, burned with red-hot objects and beaten with sticks, Rome prosecutors said.
The four absent defendants – Gen Tariq Sabir, Col Usham Helmi, Col Athar Kamel Mohamed Ibrahim and Maj Magdi Ibrahim Abdelal Sharif – all deny kidnapping Regeni.
Maj Sharif rejects a further allegation of conspiring to inflict aggravated injuries and murder. He allegedly ordered informants to spy on Regeni, who was then arrested at a metro station and tortured for several days.
The murder sparked widespread outrage and a crisis in relations between Italy and Egypt, with the Italian ambassador recalled.
Since then Egypt has dropped its own investigation, with top prosecutor Hamada al-Sawi citing “insufficient evidence”. Although Egyptian authorities admitted Regeni had been monitored and betrayed by people he had met, they refused to provide Italy with the defendants’ home details.
Italy’s ambassador is back in Cairo and President Abdul Fattah al-Sisi’s government appears to have faced no blowback at all, Mark Lowen reports.
The murdered student’s parents, Claudio Regeni and Paola Deffendi, have accused the Italian government of betrayal, by returning to business as normal with Egypt and selling two frigates as part of a large arms deal.
Meanwhile, political opponents continue to disappear. In a report last year Egypt’s Commission for Rights and Freedoms said it had documented more than 2,700 enforced disappearances since 2015. (Source: BBC)